>i dont have a gsd i was just asking whats she would do??
The cat's mother here certainly would not Alphas roll him/her nor use a pinch collar nor the choker high under the ears
I've dealt with loads of poorly socialised GSD's with this fear problem(& it is 99% fear alone)
So the dog needs good experiences near people & dogs, so I would first gain the dogs confidence then find it's safety distance(IE the distance it can be near the object of it's fear without reacting-using stooge dogs & experienced handlers)
Strangely enough even the most fearful GSDs we have had in rescue have had no problem with me or the lady who runs the rescue, probably because unlike CM we do not approach the dog head on & have no inner fear of the dog, so gaining the dogs confidence is never a problem.
Using aggression back to the dog in the form of pain/intimidation as CM does is a quick short lasting fix, that stops the behaviour by causing the dog even more suffering. Look at the eyes of the dogs CM "treats"they show the fear & submission he instills & that is no way to treat a dog. His dogs are like robots no character & they still show aggression to new comers that he allows. Dogs are social animals & a normal dog will show suspicion of a new comer but not the aggression that happens within his "pack"
TBH 50 dogs is way bigger than any "natural pack"of dogs, if you observe "feral"dog packs are never that big & ergo his dogs do not live in a real dog pack but an artifical one controlled by fear