The thing about experience is that one could be learning from the wrong people, who have never updated anything. For instance, you could find someone who has been with dogs for over 30 years and claims they know everything to know, (whereas in reality all they know is old fashioned techniques like training with a check chain) and you can have someone who has been with dogs for maybe 5 years and has better handling and training skills.
The flip side of that, is that there are some excellent trainers who are not members of any organisation and who really are very good - but they may not have a an in depth knowledge of actual
behaviour! :D Turning that over again, one of the best trainers I know has no degree but is very genned up on training and behaviour.
Updating knowledge is very important. One has only to watch the appalling tv programmes on dog training to realise that just knowing about dog training really isn't enough. I was appalled to see the treatment of one dog on a tv programme to which I knew the background. The dog was in pain but it was being handled so badly, by someone who is supposed to use reward based techniques. In spite of the dog showing calming signals and being very frightened, it was still being forced to do things it really shouldn't have been. This is where a knowledge of behaviour comes in, rather than just training.
There are a couple of people in the APBC who are basically academic behaviourists, however this is made obivious.
Most have a lot of hands on experience. I atttended a seminar for predatory chasing last autumn as it is one of my main interests, and the speaker was APBC member David Ryan who is also a Cumbrian police dog trainer and who has helped many people prevent chasing - now,that's hands on. He had the best mix - a strong grounding in hands on training and an in depth understanding of the theory side of things.
There was some concern that it was best to get a full degree because at one stage there were murmurings that only vets should be allowed to be behaviourists -heaven knows why as they are busy enough in other areas. It was felt that making training and behaviour more acceptably academic would give behaviourists who are not vets a better standing if ever their occupation was threatened, and more respect from vets etc who they may have contact with.
I don't think this will ever happen in the UK but you never know.
Lots of luck Dale in whichever path you go down for your career. It may be possible to do a fairly in depth course such as COAPE but to keep on learning by yourself, attending seminars and workshops. I'd also highly recommend training your own dog to a good standard, perhaps in a canine sport, as this will give you more confidence :)
These links may be of interest:
http://www.apbc.org.uk/career.htmhttp://www.apbc.org.uk/training_courses.htmhttp://www.coape.co.uk/courses.htmlLindsay
x