
I think the problem with this thread and others is everyone starts off trying to be really helpful, but undestandably we all think our ways are the best and some of us are rather set in them.
What we must remember is every dog/puppy is an individual just like people and will respond differently to different methods. what will work for on may not work for another. What will make one just bounce around gleefully ignoring you will have another cowering and possibly wetting itself.
I think perhaps we should just give our advice on what we would do and let the owner decide which if any of them, or which combination works best on thier pup or dog, instead of putting down others and thier methods, unless of course they are being barbaric and suggesting something cruel like tying the dog in barbed wire.
Animal communication is a great thing and many dogs problems are solved using a communicator, although i would like to add that everyone can communicate with thier animals, just try listening and hear what they say, this will help you choose which method you are going to train them with.
Bev