
Why do you hate half chokers? they are excellent type of collar. when adjusted properly they fit snugly like a buckle collar, but when not pulled tight they are nice and loose, especially good with a thick or long coated dog, as they don't wear the coat around the neck as much.
They cannot hurt the dog, as when pulled tight they just tighten to the width of the dogs neck. Also the sound ot the chain being checked alerts the dog to the fact that it is pulling, and once trained is enough to get the dog to slacken it's pace, in order to have that nice loose collar.