
Bata is a big seller so clearly people
do rate it. I think the negative posts can be disproportionate because generally people that are happy with something do not post on the internet. Infact, most of the negative posts I have read are by people who have a "theory" that it is not good as opposed to actually trying it :-)
I have used it through all the phases and my 14 year old is currently thriving on the Senior version.
Extremely well tolerated by all the dogs and puppies I have given it to and no problems at the other end either. Poos are not what I would say is excessive but not too small to cause problems with anal glands or constipation either, which was experienced by a previous dog that I tried on "low output" foods.