If the dog is good enough to beat the current top winner then it'll win, regardless ;) I don't see why such a young dog should be taken out of the ring if she is still enjoying it. Well done to her owners/breeders for such a good dog :D If they take her out of the ring what is stopping 'inferior' dogs winning? OK I know they won't be inferior, but you know what I nmean. It will mean more to people (well, to me anyway ;) ) if they beat the record holder than if they win knowing it COULD have been there, at that show, winning again. Ramble over.........