
I would need to know what the scores were like behind him & that he is an improver for HD(ie he produces better hips than himself & all the bitches he is bred to)I had such a dog he had perfect hips(yes he had a 0:0=0 hips)& of all the puppies he produced(95% of which were scored)all were better than their dams, including some 0:0=0's
Hips are not the be all & end all , but if there are two dogs of equal merit & whose pedigrees are a good match for the bitch then the lower hip scored dog that was an improver would be the one I chose
As Malcolm W says the dog is more than a part of hips !