
It is what I use as mine are a bold breed, who it won't upset, but will be enough to break into what they a re doing, it is a pretty mild aversive/negative consequence and it serves to distract them from what they a re doing so I can get them to do something positive for which they can be praised instead.
I call it my canine remote, as if they are simply ignoring a command they go quiet as soon as I say 'where's that bottle'.
With up to five dogs barking when visitors arrive I can't afford them to keep going more than absolutely necessary.
A friend with a large garden uses a hosepipe on hers if they are taking the mick and do not listen to commands of quiet.
The whole point is that a dog will choose to do what gives it pleasure and avoid doing things that are not pleasurable or unpleasant.
It is more about teaching the dog what we want it to do (instead) rather than teaching them not to do something. After all what is rewarding about not doing something?