>my parents are with E&L and they have paid out everytime and their dog is forever getting attacked by other dogs !!
It won't be all gloom and doom with E & L, they will pay out on a certain percentage of claims - they have to otherwise FSA would be down on them. An insurance product has to be viable in the market place and it must do what it says on the tin. Insurance companies would have trouble doing that if most of their claims were declined when their clients are paying to insure against risk. It would make the product worthless.
Notwithstanding, E & L have a reputation of not paying out more often compared with other insurance companies.
I like Allianz Cornhill - Petplan, changed their name to Allianz Insurance plc, decent company, decent product but not cheap. I just don't like co-excesses I.e 10% of the claim etc, etc.
More Than is a pretty good product too, Royal & Sun Alliance, although known to hike the premiums as the animal gets older.
AXA - don't like their underwriting - can be very misleading IMO.
I'm with Direct Line, I just wanted a simple life time policy, X amount per condition, with a decent company and underwriter, reasonable priced and it didn't have to cover all and sundry, just the basics. Can't really fault them but they are not very quick with processing claims, can take up to 4, 5 weeks, sometimes longer.