
I used to let my dogs off the lead from the start of the walk to the end of the walk, meeting dogs along the way, some I knew some I didn't. And we as owners used to leave it down to pot luck as to weather our dogs would get on. Most of the time but purely down to luck the dogs got on, we would loose control of our dogs for 10 mins as they raced off playing. We had no recall what so ever. Then enter another dog on to the scene weather it was on a lead or not our dogs would run over 100 miles an hour to greet it. Even the most well behaved dog would be intimidated by a pack of dogs' running towards it especially when on a lead.
we would say the "oh they are all friendly, they are only young/playing/harmless" making excuses for the real fact that we had no control over them what so ever and by saying those words would if by magic excuse the rudeness and the risk we where putting our dogs through.
In many instances the other owner would say its fine and walk off with a dozen of dogs trailing after it, tangling in the lead as the owner tried to walk away. With me and the other dog owner shouting our dogs names over and over again to death ears. Then when our dogs got back, we told them they where naughty.
then it would happen again only this time meeting a dog owner fed up of being interrupted this way, having a dog that has a medical condition/is old/scared/dog aggressive through fear what ever. And when we this time make our pitiful excuses they turn to us in a horrible tone "your dogs should be on a lead" it hurts when we here these words. The truth does hurt!
But they are right of course!
I'm shamed to say this was me as a novice dog owner who thought my dogs had a born right to wonder the fields approaching every dog and if they met a horrible dog it was the other owners fault not mine, because my dogs where perfect, would not hurt a fly.
Of course i was wrong again. Because if my dog was perfect it would never of run off, ignored my recall.
There is no excuse; the dog only knows the boundaries set by his owner!
With the amount of dogs on our dog fields at any given time, if we where all to let our dogs off all the time it would cause a mass riot I'm sure of that!
it makes no difference how good your training is, when an animal is scared or excited they are then are fuelled by instinct and so letting your dog get to this stage is just going to prove a disaster if you have no control over it.
I now view things very differently after having a dog of mine attacked, although in this case my dogs where on a lead and the attacking dogs ran out of a house and jumped on my dog. I realised how quick a dog attack can happen, I was powerless. And this was on a street with 4 other people. Had I of been on the open fields i would not have stood a chance and my dog would of probably been killed.
now my dogs start there walk on the lead and end there walk on the lead, and if they do come off lead it is when there are no other dogs in at least 100 meters of sight!
You have to be one step ahead. My dogs have learnt that recall means a treat, not "oh there's another dog/a group of kids/a bike/a jogger" they just see it as a treat opportunity. So it is a positive experience. And there recall has come on so much more better.
I never let my dogs run wild, run over to other dog even those they know, other wise that just creates double standards and causes confusion. It's best they never get the chance to run over to any dog then they don't expect the liberty.
Even dogs I know can have off days you never know what's going on in a dogs mind!
I see other dog owners letting there dogs run wild, and now I am watching from the other side of the fence i realise how wrong i was to ever let my dogs be that way. I even get annoyed with other dog owners letting there dogs approach mine, after putting all 3 in a sit and making them wait patiently in till the dog passes, I'm annoyed at the fact the owner allows there dog to approach mine and cause havoc, it isn't fair.
Unless you have a dog that never approaches other dogs no matter what then i don't see how you can ever have your dog off lead safely in a busy area and expect to have 100% control over it in all situations. So in essence you where in the wrong, and now it has taught your dog that his behaviour is acceptable.
But its ok, you now know what you need to work on. Letting dogs play together is fine, they just need to know when its time to stop, this comes only with training.