I know little about nutrition, but I admit to having fed Tansy on Bakers for a while when she was little. It is suggested often that if they don't eat their JWB for example, then let them do without because they won't starve deliberately. I may be stupid, but I just couldn't do that...so I offered her some Bakers puppy and she ate it with relish. I personally stopped giving her Bakers because it made her hyper. I suppose that is caused by the additives with some dogs. Her usual diet now is lamb or beef mince with small bites mixer. It is cheaper than dog food!! Sometimes she has chicken or liver, and she has rice and scrambled egg. I cook it in the microwave cos I just can't do Barf (shudder), and it only takes a minute or two. She eats all her food unsurprisingly LOL. If your dog is happy on Bakers then feed Bakers :-)