
i have used most kind of gadgets on my dogs as i usually try them out for the vets i work at.
head collars:
halti: found it got into their eyes and therefore do not like it - it does stop pulling tho.
gentle leader: never used but have heard good reports
dogmatic: i use and have found it so far (5 days) to be the best i have used - doesn't get into the eyes, soft, secure and gives you lots of control, it also calms mine down.
harnesses:
normal: good on small dogs but they can get out off (always use a double lead) with big dogs it gives them more to pull against.
halti: alright but my dog got used to it after a while and then learnt how to pull in it, good because it joins to a collar
lupi: never tried but i don''t really think it looks that secure.
walkezee: looks very good but i have never used it. i have heard good reports
other stop pulling ones: have heard that they cut into the dogs legs a bit
basically if i was going for a head collar i would go for a gentle leader / dogmatic (more expensive)
if i was going for a harness i would try a walkezee.
if you have a boisterous dog i would use a head collar
if you have an underconfident dog then a harness can give them some confidence (like a body wrap in TTouch)
HTH anna