
The Cinderford club is closed now, the owner living in Spain where she is running an equally successful club. I agree that it would be impossible to be all things to all people, but if you can get most of it right, then I think it is worth the effort.
I like the sound of your ringcraft clubs, the one Jackie mentions for experienced dogs..... I think that might even frighten me! lol
Anyway I am just back at ringcraft having not had a puppy for showing since 1995!!! I was expecting the ringcraft to be pretty much a case of having your dog gone over, and that is about it. The one I am going to at the moment every member of the club takes a turn to do the instruction so there is not a regular instructor.
As I have shown dogs for years, I do know what I am doing. However I do know what Bosun means, about not knowing he should have been standing his staff facing in to the judge. All breeds are different and to some extent the way they are handled is different. Flatcoats for example, always were shown "free standing" bait if it was used was kept out of sight in a pocket, they were not stacked or put into position, and certainly never were allowed to eat bait in the ring in front of a judge. This is now changed. So even within breeds things are always changing. At one time there were many people showing flatcoats on a fine show chain and black lead, before that it was just the black (or brown) lead, which fashion is now back and you'd never see a fine chain.
When the Cinderford club had a guest judge, but this was not a serious match, it was pretty much as an ordinary ringcraft class, except the judge would tell each class member how they and their dog performed that night. They'd offer tips and equally ask questions, so it was as much an exchange of information as a "match". They did have competitions against other clubs, but this was also as much a social occassion as anything.
I do think ringcraft club instructors, whether a guest or regular instructor, should try to help novices, and classes should instruct in more than going over the dog a few times. I am always interested in learning about other breeds and do attend club seminars. I have also been stewarding for years, I started this as I was interested in other breeds, I always put on the letter to a club secretary that I'd steward any breed except my own breed. I have learnt a lot from this. It made me start to look at my own breed and think for example, "Wow that dog has excellent movement" or equally "Mmmmm How did that dog manage to cross the ring?" or "What a beautiful elegant dog that is" or "Oh dear......" This is because I understood how and why other dogs were the way they are that I started to see my own breed with a fresh "eye".
Ringcraft should be a place to get information, an example of this, is my friend did not know about the ShCM award introduced by the KC, when she asked at ringcraft nobody seemed to know about it. When she rang me to ask if I knew about it, I was able to point her in the direction of the Kennel Club, since I had spotted the thread on this on Champdogs. I knew the award existed but no more than that, and since I didn't have a dog to show basically let it slip by me.