I have had a look on the internet at anti-bark collars for my 9 mth old westie there seems to be a lot of choice the spray or the noise one. Which one works the best it will only be for when he is in the garden as he barks non stop at everything when on lead or in house we never hear him has anybody had an experience with one

Hi - in my experience none are very good. The remote control ones are better, but you have to be ready at all times to press, as timing is very important. I found the citronella ones are very sensitive, you find that the poor dogs can't scratch or even sneeze without them going off. Noise ones? not tried these.