
Zuma loved 'squeekys' but did the same and ripped them up in a matter of minutes. He now has a collection of about 20 different squeekys which are all the very soft latex ones, some are at least 5 yrs old!
I think the latex is TOO soft to trash as he did get a more usual plastic one and that went in very short time.
It may be worth trying one - under supervision - to see what happens, they are normally a couple of quid so not that dear
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/TRIXIE-LATEX-DOG-AND-PUPPY-PLAY-SQUEAKY-BALL-WITH-FACE-/160480605882?var=&hash=item255d63b6ba:m:musJB2HoVgRVJ47YxO9PThgI have bought the above from local market stall for £1.50 each.
edited to add - he is not obsessive about them and if he didn't have these he would have no toys, he has a couple of nylabones - regularly chewed but tennis balls - covering ripped off!, soft toys - ripped open!, raggers - ripped and eaten!, plastic frisby type - you threw it - you fetch it!!!