
Every one of my 7 dogs is insured, and I would not have it any other way. Yes, it is expensive, yes, I have to shop around a bit but IME it is just not worth not doing.
Granted, until July I've had purebred dobermanns which are not a healthy breed; however it's actually been two of my crossbreeds who have cost the most in about a 12 month period. Healthier than purebreds they are not! One was diagnosed with HD and arthritis, spent 4 months at hydrotherapy to no avail so then had to go and have an MRI which revealed a slipped disc; she then had months of acupuncture and physio. Over £2k for that lot (which wasn't bad, really). The other has had a wonky walk for over a year now; x-ray found nothing apart from a deformed femur which happened as a pup; again she needed two MRIs and a CT scan and again a slipped disc was found, along with spondylosis under it. She also went on to have acupuncture and physio, and her bill for the last policy year went over her £2k limit. This all happened right after the first dog ran out of cover (both have £2k per year) so without the insurance, I'd have had a £4k+ bill within 12 months. The second dog also has hypothyroidism and occult DCM.
And on top of
them, my old boy also slipped a disc, more acutely; no diagnostics for him as it was obvious and he was old and wonky, but he also had to go and have acupuncture to the tune of £420. At the same time as the second dog was having hers.
I have often thought about just putting the premiums aside, but after all the above, it would be massively depleted and if something were to happen to one of them, I'd be screwed! It would take an age to get back up to a decent amount for emergencies, and they can cost a lot of money VERY quickly. One accident is enough - a friend of mine a couple of years ago was playing ball with her lab, he chased it and somehow managed to catch his muzzle on the ground, flipped over and popped a disc very badly. Paralyzed. After a lot of rehab and hydro he can walk again, in his own way; but it cost her a fortune. Totally freak accident and that is primarily why I have insurance - with the healthiest dog in the world, these things can still happen.