
You don't say if this figure is for motility or morphology or total number of sperm. Speaking as the owner of a 9 year old stud dog myself, if it's for a natural mating and the bitch is young and fertile, I would go for it if this is the dog they really want to use. I had a semen evaluation done last year which indicated that although overall the semen was in good shape for his age and his motility was pretty good, there were some age-related signs in the morphology of a percentage of the sample - in other words, there were some changes to the shape of some of the sperm (common in an older dog), but the normal sperm were still swimming strongly. I was advised that although he would still be able to fertilise a bitch with a natural mating, he was borderline for freezing. He had an older bitch up for mating the following month, and she produced a litter of five.
I was also advised that fertility will fall off rapidly if dogs of this age are not used regularly, which is never the case in my breed. I would probably try the combination only once to see - if the bitch failed to get in whelp, I would probably look for a son of the old boy for the next time, particualrly if she were an older bitch. He will be still less fertile in six months time. My dog is semi-retired now (actually not because of fertility, but because in a small gene pool he's sired enough - he's generally no longer available, unless on a bitch of very different lines to those he's sired on before), and will be completely by his 10th birthday.