
Sorry I am having a cynical day but...why is she breeding ? Is it for something to keep for the showring, to improve the breed or just to have a pup for herself?
Falling in love with a sire is not the right criterea for choosing him. If I were her I would be looking for a used boy who knows his job. For 2 novices to start with 2 unexpierienced dogs is not the best start. There are lots of dogs I love but not many are the right ones for my bitches
Does he compliment her bitch? how does she know he is a good example if he is never shown? It sounds like his temperament is not 100%.
Forgive me if I am reading your post wrong but I do think a little more in depth reserch is needed. There are lots of good males out showing themselves to be worthy of breeding , tell her to have a look for an expierienced stud.
Aileen