Not logged inChampdogs Information Exchange
Topic Dog Boards /
Breeding / Advice needed - litter registered with incorrect sire (locked)
By LJS
Date 07.10.10 18:05 UTC

Emma sorry missed your post then if so cheap to have it done it seems a no brainer to implement then ? :-)
Yes, but that is per dog! So, say you have a litter of 10 pups (not uncommon in my breed) it will cost you £25 by 12 cos mum and dad have to be done too...... Who wants to add £300 to their running costs?

Going back to the original topic - it only needs a stud dog at open stud to be DNA'd to deter fraudsters.
By Brainless
Date 07.10.10 23:45 UTC
Edited 07.10.10 23:47 UTC

How unless puppies are DNA'd?
And what is Open stud?
I would expect stud dogs only to be available to bitches whose pedigrees and conformation make the dog a desirable match, so no dog should be available except to suitable bitches.
.
>And what is Open stud?
I thought Open Stud was a term used in the cat fancy, where it seems most stud cats are only used on their owner's queens, and a cat at Open Stud is available to others. Totally different to the dog fancy, where a breeder using their own dog would be viewed with suspicion!
By theemx
Date 08.10.10 09:09 UTC
> Yes, but that is per dog! So, say you have a litter of 10 pups (not uncommon in my breed) it will cost you £25 by 12 cos mum and dad have to be done too...... Who wants to add £300 to their running costs?
Er... come on, a litter of 10, even at the lower end of the price range, lets say £500 per pup.... thats £5K.... £300 out of 5k is NOT a lot at all.
Average puppy prices in my two breeds are around the £850 mark these days.. Deerhounds will easily have 10 puppies... Tibetan Terriers ok no not ten. but still.. I could see someone breeding something with large litters but a very low average price, say Whippets, those are pretty cheap in comparison to a LOT of breeds... if you are only getting £300/400 per pup then £300 to DNA all the pups is a big chunk...
And of course.. mum and dad only need doing the once..

How is the DNA actually done? May be missing something here but is it a official/vet that takes the sample otherwise its no guarantee of anything?
By LJS
Date 08.10.10 13:24 UTC
Yes, but that is per dog! So, say you have a litter of 10 pups (not uncommon in my breed) it will cost you £25 by 12 cos mum and dad have to be done too...... Who wants to add £300 to their running costs? That can be easily consumed and can be passed on in the price of the puppies as do the other costs involved in having a litter ? Paying 500 or 525 for a pup would not be a great deterant for most prospective puppy buyers I would have thought :-) As I said if it were to become common practice DNA tests costs would ultimate reduce as there would be a competative market place created for the tests :-)
"That can be easily consumed and can be passed on in the price of the puppies as do the other costs involved in having a litter ?"
Consuming about £25 is one thing but actually going through with the parental DNA identifications is going to be roughly an additional three times that cost. That's a big increase in the price for the puppy purchaser to pay if they want actual proof of their puppy's parentage.
By LJS
Date 08.10.10 14:23 UTC

I am confused then ? Are we saying the DNA profile of the Dam and Sire would be more expensive ? If so then how much as it would only have to be done once and so the cost would be pro-rated across maybe a couple of litters on the Dams side but maybe more frequent for the sire as is it more likely that the dog will statistically sire more than a couple of litters ?
I have never actually DNA tested a litter for parentage and I was asking in an earlier post if anyone does have this experience.
Not only is there the cost of gathering DNA samples from the parents and puppies but the additional testing for parental identification and the Vet's consultation fees for taking all the swabs and reading microchips etc.
So going back to my original question if the KC do not supply the result to the owner of any dog they DNA test then they lock in all further testing to their services only. I presume it is not possible to use a cheaper service provided elsewhere once the KC service has been initially used.
But why should I DNA my litter when I know who the parents are? I agree that they should be done if there is any chance that someone is trying to defraud, but if I use a friends dog over my bitch, why should I be made to DNA test the litter?
The KC should not allow full registration to go through until they have the stud dogs agreement that their dog is 100% the father. Any doubt and they should ask for DNA. I don't think that it should be mandatory. After all, even using the old way of actually signing the litter registration form is open to cheating. It has always been based on trust. If the stud dog owner is unhappy then there should be ways of preventing full registration.
So I am now asking myself exactly what use the KC DNA profiling service is. As far as I can see it is not mandatory to enter a microchip number for the dog to be DNA profiled. Extract from the Application Form reads...........
"Owners should be aware that throughout this process, the issue of trust is a major factor, as owners may take and submit DNA samples without a dog being positively identified."
http://www.thekennelclub.org.uk/download/1329/dnaparentanalysis.pdf
I have just spoken to a friend who DNA tested for paternity. If the sample is a cheek swab you can do it yourself. The vet does not become involved. If, however, you do a blood DNA sample then it obviously has to be the vet who does it, so it will cost more than the £25 per dog.
It all comes down to the same trust that we have in using the snail mail kc registration forms.
By LJS
Date 08.10.10 15:54 UTC

Problem is trust is no way to run a scheme as human nature means there will always be an element that will break that trust if money is involved :-)

There will always be people who cheat; there's absolutely no way to guarantee anything like that. So we're stuck with trust.
By LJS
Date 08.10.10 16:20 UTC

I would think a more robust process is better than trust ! :-)

Well our pups are £650, first time litter with stud fee and health tests will cost you £200 per puppy (6 is avearage). That is without the rest of the usual puppy costs.
My vet charges over £50 for a blood sample, and £28 for walking through the door so am sure that coming out to DNA swab a litter or even going to the Vet (if you drive and have someone who can help you take a whole litter at once, will make it cheaper), and then the cost per puppy might add £50 to each puppy, and that's before a penny has been spent on bitch and pups care.
> So I am now asking myself exactly what use the KC DNA profiling service is
That is why I don't bother with it, see no point. Gives the false impression to puppy buyers that the pups parentage
has been verified, not just that it
can be.
By Schip
Date 09.10.10 12:49 UTC
Edited 09.10.10 12:52 UTC
All my dogs are DNA profiled, any dog I want to use at Stud will not be used if their owner isn't willing to DNA profile for me its simple. My breed is a minority I don't need to do any mandatory health screening but do Hips, Eyes, MPS, Thyroid and patella's because I want to see if there are hidden problems developing.
I like to have all my breeding animals DNA on file as a precaution and more than happy for KC or puppy buyer to do a paternity test as I know my dogs are who I claim they are. Same with any male that is used at Stud, his profile is already on record alleged breeders can pay to prove their pedigree or I take matter up with KC/breeder via a solicitor to prevent my dogs name being used against a bitch he hasn't mated. Also think trading standards might be able to help here too as it is Fraud after all and the KC aren't really doing their cause any favours by not having security protocols in place to prevent such Fraud.
We as breeders should give the assurance to potential buyers that they can indeed verify via DNA any pup purchased from us if they so wish at their own expense.
By Harley
Date 09.10.10 12:50 UTC

Sticking my head above the parapet now :-) I see so many posts from reputable, responsible breeders who state that they only breed a litter of puppies when they want one themselves - and that is the right thing to do IMHO. In the process of getting a pup for themselves they end up with more pups than the one they need and those are the pups that are sold to other people. So surely the largest expenses incurred for the stud fee, extra food for the bitch, whelping etc would be incurred whether it was a singleton puppy or a whole litter and the other costs would onlygo up in relation to how many pups were born - puppy food, registration etc?
So when working out the cost of a pup that is to be sold, and the increase on price if DNA testing was undertaken, why are the costs for stud fee, whelping etc included as part of that equation? Those costs are a part of getting the one pup that is needed for the breeder to keep with the other pups, who are surplus to requirements, being a "bonus" for recouping some of the expenditure incurred to get the puppy who will remain with the breeder.
This is not a criticism in any way, shape or form - just interested in the thinking behind the way the sale price for a puppy is arrived at. If, as a breeder, you only ever got one puppy instead of a whole litter would you still breed or would it be far too expensive to make it viable?
By MADDOG
Date 09.10.10 15:51 UTC
But they need your males KC number dont they?KC registration numbers are in the public domain. If there are hereditary health tests required by KC in a breed then there will be a list somewhere & anyone can get hold of that registration number (just google your dog's kc number & try it!) I had this conversation in the summer & was told that I was being over dramatic, but here is a case in point.
I would DNA profile everything but I don't believe that the KC should charge so much for it if it becomes compulsory. My dogs have DNA tests for hereditary health tests so in theory their DNA is already in a database somewhere.
I don't know where you stand regarding this, but perhaps it's about time the KC put password protection on this so that the stud dog owner gives the bitch's owner a password only after they are happy to do so (this password would require a time limitation or similar I suppose)

Now that sounds do-able.
Or unless the stud dog owner has to validate/confirm that a mating to 'x' bitch has taken place on 'x' dates?.
All that the stud dog owner would need is a record of the bitches KC registered name and owners names
at time of mating (which most reputable stud dog owners keep proper records anyway)...
and KC would just have to send an email (doesn't have any cost to the KC as such) to stud dog owner to ask them to confirm this mating took place if the litter is registered on line rather than via the paper form.
Assuming that the detail of email address of stud dog owner is required when registering the litter on line?
Simples....??
If the KC made it compulsory it would bring the cost down by default anyway, the more done the cheaper. We have to DNA profile sire, dam and progeny with the horses we breed. Have done for years now and it was never an issue with people when it was first brought out so I don't see why dog people are so against it.
I have long campaigned this is the way the KC registrations should go. It would do alot to curb some of the puppy farmers who get wealthy churning out pedigree pups. I worked out a puppy farmer in my own breed out of 4 litters in the past 12 months has raked in £27,200 on pups, and £4,000 on stud fees for his dog. Plus the bitches that have been farmed out in other people's names to have litters for him. Would someone like that go through DNA profiles when they do not even worm or vaccinate their pups? Probably not.
Yes it would make it more expensive to breed a litter but for those who really care about their breed and maybe only breed when they themselves want a new generation, or when they have enough puppy buyers waiting the extra cost should not be a deterant. After all they are hardly in it for the money. And for future generations even if there is no hereditary disease in that breed now, that may arise at some point and the more DNA of ancestors stored the quicker the research can start into the origin.
By crofty
Date 13.10.10 11:27 UTC
Hi,
I am have recently spoken to the kennel club and they have raised my objection to the man concerned. They are presently waiting for him to prove that my dog is the sire. Unfortunately they have said they can do no more & if the puppies do end up with their new owners it will not be until they try to transfer ownership that they will realise there is a problem. The Kennel club do not tell the new owners the problem, they have to go back to the breeder. I am hoping that at least one of the new owners will pursue the matter, so that this can get resolved. I do understand that the kennel club could see this as a dispute between me and the breeder, just so frustrating for me as this man is getting away with it. I did have my sister contact him, and he sent thru some photos of mum & dad, the dad was not the registered sire of the litter (ie not my dog). Also the dog that is the dad is not the same colour as my dog, but of course KC papers wont tell the new owners that.
The Kennel club have assured me that they will keep me informed??
x
> I did have my sister contact him, and he sent thru some photos of mum & dad, the dad was not the registered sire of the litter (ie not my dog). Also the dog that is the dad is not the same colour as my dog, but of course KC papers wont tell the new owners that.
But it might ring some alarm bells if colours are produced which would be impossible genetically from the registered [= your] dog. Or is that not an issue in this case?
Thanks for the update - unfortunately it looks as though it will take some time to resolve. Please let us know when you have any new developments.
You must be so stressed about it - I just don't know how I would react if anything similar happened to me.
If, as a breeder, you only ever got one puppy instead of a whole litter would you still breed or would it be far too expensive to make it viable? You know what, that would be my ultimate DREAM! One puppy per litter, no need to sell, loads of time to spend on just one pup -bliss!! The one time I had a litter like that convinced me it was just perfect -and that dog has turned out absolutely fantastic as far as temperament goes as well. It does save money as well because there is no need to microchip say ten pups, no need to register ten, no need to feed ten. I absolutely hate the time between, say 3 weeks and 8 weeks, when you have a whole litter, and cannot start to enjoy it at all until there is just ONE pup left -mine. If I could be assured of one pup per litter I'd feel able to breed more often -now it is just once every two years for my large breed.
They can do no more??? Good grief this is the 21st C, not the middle ages. There is DNA profiling- can be done swifly and cheaply. You as the dog owner say your dog did NOT sire this litter. They should act NOW. Not allow the pups to be registered, sold, and the IF the new owners decide to query parentage (which they probably will not once they have paid out for a pup and papers) then act. If I were you write to both dog papers, make this public. The KC sticks it's head in the sand about too many things until it is too late. What happens if 2 yrs down the line these pups show to have inherited disease and start dying young - your dog will be to blame on paper.

I am sure the KC will/have now cancelled the registrations, but the people who have already gone off with their pups and KC paperwork, and not bothered to transfer the ownership (at least half in my experience) the KC will be unable to contact them, so they won't know.
I am sure there is no issue of them believing the stud dog owner, as with there being a query they will be able to DNA.
My understanding is that the KC will request the Registration papers to be returned if they have been already sent out. The KC will have notified the breeder that there is a dispute over the sire and will request he submit evidence to prove that the dog he said was the sire is the sire.
This may start out with a stud contract with dam. date etc on it. but if this is not forthcoming then DNA would be asked.
DNA for identity can be done with the KC DNA Profiling. The dam and all prospective sire as well as all puppies would need to be DNA profiled. (my dogs are already DNA profiled so in my case when i had a oops mating all i needed to do was the Puppies)
The cost of each test is £25 currently and then there is an extra £25 to prove parentage.
In this case 9 pups, his dam, your sire is £275 plus £25 to prove parentage. If your dog isnt proven the sire then they would need for him to get his possible sires DNA profiled too.
The KC always do send out the letter of confirmation but it is also a good idea to be vigilant with the BRS when it comes out.
BTW i had this issue when i saw in the Gazette an affix close to my own on a pet litter. I then received the BRS and found a litter registered with that affix in my own breed. I wrote and complained and my complaint was witheld and the affix denied. As this litter was registered 2 months before the affix was approved i am waiting to see if the litter is reregistered in the next BRS.
im wondering now about the kc has our boy sired a litter pups are now 3weeks old ,owner reg them the next day they were born and has his papers work back BUT the kc havnt been intouch to make sure this litter was sired by my boy, this is his 1st mating to a outside bitch ,i thought the kc got intouch with the stud owner everytime? its no good sending out the paper work 1st then to find your boy hasnt done the deed (in my case he has) but it does worry me now ....and looseing faith with the kc
You as stud dog owner who sired the litter are required to sign the registration papers before they are sent to the KC. If you have not signed them either the KC is negligent in registering a litter without the signature. Or the bitch owner has forged your signature?
By Emz77
Date 19.10.10 10:35 UTC

white lilly my boy has sired 4 litters always outside my breeding and i have NEVER had any correspodence from the KC when the litters have been registered, (all 4 have been registered using the online service) It is a worry as those people have hold of your studs reg number they could register any litters against him that aren't his. It's disgusting if you ask me.
By Emz77
Date 19.10.10 10:36 UTC

harkback you don't need a signature when registering a litter online. You just need the stud dogs name and reg number

Harkback, this refers to On-line registration.
Paper registration will not go through without stud dog owners signature (though of course whose to say it is their signature) so there has always been scope for people to register litters using the name of someones dog, and people unless very vigilant checking when the BRS is published (and how many people buy these?).
This is why it should be freely available to view not just for those wishing to buy it. then everyone could see who registers what and how often and what the health test results are.
Also it would get over the issue of what is a volume breeder, good breeder, who health tests etc. Buyers could make their own minds up if they could check in advance how often the breeder whose litter they are looking at has registered puppies, how often bred from that bitch, how often teh stud had been used, what their and relatives health test results were etc, if they had an open database like the Finnish Kennel club 'Koiranet'

Then you need to contact the Kennel Club and ask why. As far as I was aware, and that is what it says on their site, that the stud dog owner is written to in each case.
By Emz77
Date 19.10.10 11:00 UTC

That does sound like a very good idea what the finnish have. It's a shame it isn't over here really as more people would look at this than bother getting the BRS like you said how many people buy that? I bet the average owner looking for a puppy doesn't!

Also the BRS only covers a given Quarter, not what a person reserching either a dog, litter or breeder needs.
Hello everyone
I'm new here and sorry to bring this topic up to the start again but I just wanted to add my experience of this happening.
We have a huge problem in our breed which is numerically small with a puppy farmer well known to the KC registering false litters. Already we have had a litter recalled to be DNA profiled and only some of them turned out to be the correct parentage. I have a rescue with me at the mo who was sold as a registered dog but I know they are not. They are currently being DNA profiled.
I have spoken with Trading Standards about the way the KC registers litters and they are in agreement with me that they are not carrying out due diligence when registering litters. I can see how trust came into it in years gone by but nowadays there are so many people using dogs to make money that this is not a sound way to use a registry. If you think about it, everything in life sees us having to prove our identity. Why does this not happen with litters of dogs? It must be awful to buy a dog thinking it has a good pedigree, only to find out it hasn't and when you do raise the query with the KC they are very reluctant to do anything about it unless YOU can prove your concern. This is not good and I personally think that its down to making money. We need a robust, suresafe way of knowing that the puppies we buy are actually from the said parents.
THis happens more than you would think. I have been doing research lately on this very topic and it would make your hair curl when you see what people get away with and continue to get away with by the KC.
I hope this person gets things sorted but if they want to PM me I can provide them with extra info to add weight to their case.
Thanks for listening

Although I find it disgusting that the KC don't seem to be doing anything, we do have to PROVE things no matter what before anything can be done no matter what it is in life that we are referring to.
Myself I think these breeders who are doing this should not be allowed to register anymore litters, especially once proven that the details are incorrect.

The principle of 'innocent until proven guilty' is the mainstay of our democracy.

The 'Register of Births' (for people) is still down to trust, and we all knwo that often the father on the birth certificate is not the father in fact.
Yes, you're right the register of births is still down to trust and I agree with that. I do think though that in the area of dog breeding and the fact that lots of people use it as a way of making money, it would be correct to have a more robust registration system in place. The people that are honest and trustworthy have nothing to fear, but it may stop some of the more unscrupulous characters from registering fraudulent litters. This can do untold damage to a breed. I would like to think that a person I was buying a puppy from was honest but most of these unscrupulous breeders talk a good talk. Its not the more experienced people that get caught out but the unsuspecting puppy purchasers - and there are lots of them - that are more often the victims of this practice. There are flaws in any system but the system of registering puppies at the moment is unbelievable. I think this needs to be moved into the 21st century. The only way this could be fail-safe is for a vet to take the DNA samples when the puppies are born. In some countries in Europe is it not the case that its not the registration certificate that's important but the pedigree which is sent to the new owner following confirmation of parentage through DNA profiling. This makes sense but it would have to move to a government body for it to happen. Of course these are my thoughts and if there were checks in place there would be no heartache for people who buy the puppies. I know that because I'm dealing with one of them!!! It's a horrible situation to find yourself in.

Just read this and thought I would comment on a friend getting a letter from the KC for verification of her stud being used and he had been dead 3 yrs, the females owner had had a male pup from them several years before and then asked his breeder to lift the breeding endorsement on him, his owners were told to get the PRA testing done and they would consider it, he was never tested,never heard anything more till this letter appearred and it turned out this male actually sired the pups and his sire who had been PRA checked and clear put down on the paperwork.
My friend said this was the first time the KC had sent them a letter since online litter registration had started, they then asked for a list of litters her studs were supposed to have sired to compare with their paperwork, the KC were reluctant to do so at first but eventually came up with the list, there were no more problems.
The folk who fraudulently registered the litter were dealt with by the KC., this certainly messes up any pedigrees that follow on from this sort of thing.
What concerns me is when websites ask for your dogs Reg No. before listing them leaving them open to anyone using them fraudulently.
It amazes me the cons that some folk will get involved in.
The only way this could be fail-safe is for a vet to take the DNA samples when the puppies are bornHow is this a failsafe? the puppies being sampled would need permanently identified first to make the sample worth anything (due to the fact there could be more than 1 sire to a litter). I certainly wouldn't microchip before 8 weeks in my breed.
Angela
>The only way this could be fail-safe is for a vet to take the DNA samples when the puppies are born.
>How is this a failsafe? the puppies being sampled would need permanently identified first to make the sample worth anything (due to the fact there could be more than 1 sire to a litter). I certainly wouldn't microchip before 8 weeks in my breed.
Add to that fact that they can't be tested before 4 weeks of age (and preferably weaned from mum) due to cross contamination of DNA from mum.
If there are identifying marks on the dog it can be done at 4 weeks. I had a litter which contained, Liver, Black, and liver and tan. The Liver and tans were the problem as there were three males but each had a different amount of white on their chests so i put these marks down as the different identifiers. Once the dogs were microchipped and registered i could update the profiles with the correct data.
You do have to profile every puppy though, just in case of multiple sires. This is rare but can happen, especially if an older dog has been used at stud, but there is a younger male on the property.
I had pups litter eye tested at 6-8 weeks so will have them microchipped at that time if possible.
Topic Dog Boards /
Breeding / Advice needed - litter registered with incorrect sire (locked)
Powered by mwForum 2.29.6 © 1999-2015 Markus Wichitill