> Personally I think it is really cruel not to walk your dogs on a regular basis unless you are really ill
To me that doesn't make sense - why is it cruel for the dog not to get walked regularly if you are well, but not if you are ill? I would imagine - at least in my case - if I knew I had a long term illness that meant I couldn't walk a dog regularly, I either wouldn't have one, would have arrangements for a dog walker for them - or would take on an oldie that didn't need/ want the walks.
It really does depend on age, breed (eg. young gundogs, collies, working dogs NEED their physical and mental stimulation or you will know about it!!) and health of the dog. Not aimed at you, just generally, but as humans we have a tendency to anthropomorphise, and we have this idea dog = must be walked - dogs get enjoyment from plenty other things in life - the ones that live for their walks have that 'rigid walking at certain times' daily routine often and love the routine as much as the walks. Dogs are creatures of habit. Not that I'm suggesting fit and healthy dogs should not be walked regularly, far from it - what I said in my first post is what I think - regular walks are part of the dog-owning package we take on as humans.
But a day that springs to mind that my dog didn't get walked, as in I didn't take him out for 'his' walk was last July, my mother's birthday party. But he got lead walked to the bus stop, trip across town on the bus, and the afternoon/ evening trotting round house/ garden with all sorts of people, and a queue of children aged between 7 and 12 taking turns to throw a football for him - I had to call a halt for a rest, lol!! And he was tired out the next day, as compared with how he would be after his usual walk - think he got quite enough mental and physical stimulation. Her garden is also on the edge of rural, and has lots of interesting sniffs - he loves sniffing his way round it!
But since he will be 10 this year and has a bad back - he doesn't NEED his walks the same as he did when he was a fit raring to go 2 yr old, and he doesn't get as much as a result - he stiffens up if he overdoes it. Think I said that earlier though. And hope I am making sense - not on top form today.