just read in our dogs a critique for my girl (Beardie) who was 1st at open show in Lunesdale the judge got her name right but thats about all... said she was slate and she is fawn said she had a nice dark eye she has an amber eye being fawn.... the write up was good but doesnt sound like it was hers!!

Anyone else had this .....

~Roni

Never had that extream but I had a handling criteqe recently that praised me sooo highly with no faults but places above me had faults... people have said to me and my parents they can't understand it, I guess judges get confused....or make it up when they get home!!!!!! ;)

Albert White two years ago did a lovely critique of the first place winners dog on mine.  Everybody realised who he was describing as the two dogs were totally different.  Made us laugh.