
I agree I would let them play together.
Granted my oldest girl was approx 18m when we brought the new puppy in and it took about a week for her to accept the pup following her around and wanting to snuggle up to her but when she realised that she wasnt a threat and that they could actually play together she let her into her crate ...with her lie on top of her to keep warm and sleep.... puppy pinched all her toys (eventhough she did have her own ) it didnt bother Ellie one bit they are now inseperable the oldest being 2y and 9m old pup.
we often just sit and watch them playing... rolling around and chasing each other and know it was the best thing we've ever done.
Supervised play is the way to go ....remembering to not make to much fuss of puppy I'd bring them into the living room in the evening with me and let them mix together.
Roni