Thanks for the feedback Charliesgirl. Since vets know nothing about calcium supplementation for worrying behaviours during lactation, the only evidence people have to go on is when people like you report back like this.
>Can I please ask what is the better product the Colloquial cal d or Now Calcium carbonate ( for a newly whelped bitch) thanks
There is not really a 'better' product, as they can all work a little differently. But whatever product you buy, you need the info on it to tell you how much elemental calcium is in it - not just how much calcium carbonate/citrate etc etc, but how much of that is elemental calcium.
Dicalcium phosphate and calcium carbonate are best taken with food for absorption and may take a little longer to kick in. Calcium citrate is faster working and does not need to be taken with food.
Ideally if you are supplementing long-term throughout lactation (which many choose to do, preventatively), then you need a product which is balanced for calcium to phosphorus ratios. In the US there is a great product called Doc Roys Healthy Bones, which is excellent and what I use - I don't know if you can ship that here or find it on Amazon, but I get family members to bring it back when they are on trips in the US! If you are just supplementing for a few days or shorter term, then balanced Ca:Ph ratios are less important.