
If you're struggling with treats, make your own - you can substitute ingredients if need be or just do small chopped cooked bits of whatever raw meats he can have. Mine get chopped duck gizzards - they are the perfect treat! Great texture, don't crumble, easy to cook (chuck in bowl of water, microwave for 30 minutes/40 if frozen) and only one ingredient. Absolute godsend for my dog who's allergic to a lot of proteins.