Not logged inChampdogs Information Exchange
By Shirley
Date 13.09.02 10:53 UTC
Hi all
Haven't posted for some time, but had a bit of a fright (well, my ten year old daughter did) this morning. Rhum, my 20 month old Vizsla, lunged & snapped at my daughter. Story goes: She gave him something to eat in his bowl and remained close to him (although has been told to leave him be when eating), he did a rumbly growl and then went off to his basket and lay down. She approached him and "told him off" and he (remained lying down) lunged forward and snapped at her, then went into total submissive mode. She shouted for me (I was upstairs) and by the time I got there, the dog was a quivering heap (obviously knew he had done wrong). I reprimanded him verbally but had to spend most of the time comforting my daughter. After about 20 minutes, I got her to make him come to her (which he did in crawl, submissive mode) and make him sit and lie down and then got her to send him back to his bed. I have phoned the vet who immediately said that it was territorial "aggression" and that the dog had only given a warning - "if he'd wanted to bite, he would have got her". He agrees with me that perhaps we should "neuter him" and that this will lesson the "aggression" but may not cure it. Overall, Rhum is very loving and well behaved and obedient - he has not snarled or been nasty aggressive, but he is very protective over chew bones and "his space" - but then, that is probably normal with most dogs (just our Rough Collie was so placid!). I feel that we should respect his space & feed if thats what he wants us to do. I mean, I think of my bedroom as my private area and I'd get cheesed off if someone took my dinner away or annoyed me when I'm eating!
Please give me all advice you can.
Shirley (and a quivering Rhum)
By Pammy
Date 13.09.02 13:23 UTC
Hi Shirley
Sorry to hear of this problem with Rhum. It's so distressing when they act out of character like this. Typical of the vet to suggest castrating him from the off. Castration may be the answer - it may not. I wonder if Rhum is actually feeling allright and whether a trip to the vets for him to check him over would be in order.
I feel a dog should not be territorial over it's food or space with any human member of the household - although they have to be allowed their own time etc and should not be pestered when eating or trying to rest. The actions sound rather odd. Sorry I can't be of anymore help - but I do wonder if a check up would help - rule illness out if nothing else.
Good luck
Pam n the boys
By Bec
Date 13.09.02 14:27 UTC
I think your daughter left it too late to reprimand him for grumbling earlier, you telling him off again at a later stage wouldn't have helped either. A dog needs to know at the point it has done soemthing wrong that it has done something wrong.
With regards to his behaviour he could just be feeling a bit under the weather and this may be why he reacted so. Dogs are entitled to their off days as we are.
By theemx
Date 13.09.02 14:43 UTC

Be very careful about t;he neutering thing, i got rocky neutered at 18 months, and it opened up a whole can of worms as it took away a lot of his confidence which means that he will now fight with other dogs where previously he never saw the need too.
In my house i will not tolerate any kind of growling at me or my house mate over food or possessions. it could well be that your dog had an off day though.
if your dog learns that when he growls or snaps he gets his own way then you have a big big problem. its not so bad in your own home, with your family, as they will know the rules, but what if a child tried to take somthing off him out doors and he did it? i know it is just a what if? but it is better to ask these questions now than when it is too late.
if your daughter is not scared, then you should get her to feed him and train him, which will teach him to respect her, as well as you!
But like others have said, it could jsut be that he had an off day! we all have them from time to time!
Emma
By Naomi
Date 13.09.02 14:53 UTC
Sounds to me like he may not be feeling 100%
It's a bit odd if he's never acted that way before and knew that his behaviour was unacceptable.
By Ingrid
Date 13.09.02 16:07 UTC
One thing I have learned from experience is that 10 yo girls don't always tell you the full story (I've had 2 now thankfully a lot older) so are you sure she didn't do anything else that caused him distress ? One of my previous dogs used to act like this if he snappped at someone, he immediately went all submissive as he knew it was wrong.
I have always believed that I should be able to take anything away from my dogs, you never know when they will get hold of something that could be dangerous to them, I don't tend to take bones or food away but know that I can if I need to. I also believe that a dog should have a place that it can retreat to and be left alone, we all need space sometimes. Ingrid
By mr murphy
Date 13.09.02 17:00 UTC
I dont think children of ten should be feeding a dog on their own. It could be a recipe for disaster. Especially with a young maturing dog of 20 months. at this stage in the dogs development it could have thought for a moment that it was higher in the pecking order than the child. I only allow myself or my wife (dominant male and female in the dogs mind) to feed the dogs anything. I stick to the idea of the alpha male and female and pack pecking order.
Is your dog allowed on the seats/bed etc?. Is your daughter allowed to give tit bits of any kind to the dog?. If so I would stop this at once and enforce a strict order for a while. Simple rules like you all eat before the dog, not at the same time. Never allow the dog to go through a door or gate first. Always you, you are the leader. No beds or seats, these are reserved for pack leaders. No human tit bits. IE sweets/cakes/human food/etc. Dont wait for him to wake up to go a walk. Wake him up. Why? Because you can. Your the boss. Sounds silly/harsh, maybe it does work.
All the best Mick.
PS, Dont wait till its too late.
By mari
Date 13.09.02 17:43 UTC
Iam afraid I must agree with Mick .
The cardinal rule respect it is an animal and never never let a child alone with a dog .
Then you will be certain sure they are safe,
Mari

These are only my thoughts which may be wrong but you say he growled then retreated to his bed your daughter followed reprimanded him then he lunged and went submissive. Is your daughter 100% sure that she had not begun the row before he made for his bed so in his eyes he was backing down and was followed and cornered so felt he had to retaliate. I am not saying that his reaction was right but understandable if this is how he saw things. You say your daughter has been told not to stay close to him when eating any special reason? If you are not happy for her to be close to him when he is eating perhaps it would be better if she only gave him food when you are present.
Maybe a check up with vet in case he is under the weather. Just keep an eye on things but don't overreact as this might make problem worse. As you didn't see what happened give him the benefit of the doubt while keeping kid(s) safe
Anne
By Sharon McCrea
Date 13.09.02 18:55 UTC
Hi Shirley, I agree with what everyone else says. Get the vet to check him over, and if you feel you must, try chemical/hormonal castration before you have surgery. Rhum's at that difficult age so hopefully it will be a one off thing, but if he was mine I'd first take his food/toys/bones away myself for a moment or two before giving them back on a regular basis. Then if that goes OK, after a few days I'd get my daughter to do it, first under my obvious supervision, then with me lurking close by but out of Rhum's sight (and hopefully nose and hearing). And if he makes any aggressive move under any of those conditions, I'd roar at him and - putting on my tin helmet again - I'd give him an instant hard smack on the rump.
By aoife
Date 13.09.02 22:07 UTC
i have three girls aged 6,2, and nine months, from the time apup comes in our home on two of the feeds the two girls sit by the pup genle strocking pup and saying good girl/boy while pup is eating they put hands in the bowl and let the pup eat out of there hand, i myself have done this before i had children with g.s.d have never had a dog yet snap or gett funny over food or anything, i never leave my children and dog alone i trust the dogs ninty percent, i more worried incase my children did somthing to my dogs, two storys, eight year old g.s.d good loving family pet, child aged two left in room together for short time, dog bites the child, for what seems no apparent reason, family devistated by the child being bitten and that there gentle dog could of done this, dog put to sleep, a post mortem was carried out on the dog and they found a pencil pushed as far as it could go in to the dogs ear drum.
story no two, eight year old child given some responsability in caring for dog, was able to take it for a short walk around the block, allowed to groom it etc, child began to resent these tasks and when taking the dog outside started to kick it and beat it, dog eventualy groweled at child every time it came near it, dog rehomed more problems serfaced, fear of children after several homes was put to sleep regards tina
By philippa
Date 13.09.02 22:11 UTC
Hi Tina, Those stories are awful, they made my toes curl up, those poor poor dogs.:(
By aoife
Date 13.09.02 22:36 UTC
hi phillipa,
this is what happens time and time again, how do you teach people common sense, i so want to have a litter with my bitch she is doing very well for me in the ring, she has so much to offer the breed if i put her to the right stud dog as she is as close to the breed standard as far as size goes and that is what i want in a whippet bitch not these over sized rangey dogs, but i am getting myself in a state even thinking about finding loving homes for them, it scares me to death.regards tina
By philippa
Date 13.09.02 22:50 UTC
Hi again Tina, with one exception I have never homed any of our pups to families with children under five. This probably sounds very unfair, and I truly believe that a childhood is not complete without a much loved dog around, but I dont think children under five, that live with an average family ( not totally dog orientated like us) can be expected to be totally sensible around a young pup or dog. I think children who belong to folk like us are taught from the very beginning to respect and care for animals. However I feel that if a pup is bought into a "non doggy" household than problems will arise. I dont think any mum can keep an eye on the children for 24/7, and problems will arise, and normally its the poor old dog that gets the blame. I cant bear to think about the pain that dog must have suffered with a pencil in its ear drum!!!!!! If it really bothers you, best safe than sorry, and dont sell to anyone with young chjildren. I know exactly what you mean, it worries me a lot too, hence I havnt bred a litter of Wolfhounds for the last five years. All the best if you do decide to breed in the end. There is one solution however, keep all the pups yourself :D
By mari
Date 13.09.02 23:54 UTC
I agree some children are very cruel Phillipa .
But Some even babies are just born dog lovers from the cot .
Kalem never pinched or pulled Berry
Lorraine was the same , Sharon was not so patient she bit the behind off our german shepherd for blocking her way out . poor thing he just yelped and she stood there two and a half years old with his hair in her mouth.
I was speaking very sternly to her for doing it and he just stood in front of her to protect her .
Another dog may have reacted.
So they are all different and so again do not let a child alone with a dog . for both of their safety
By philippa
Date 14.09.02 00:26 UTC
Hi Mari, I agree with you totally. Children that are brought up in real doggy families usually are really good with dogs and pups. I was thinking more along the lines of a child who had not been brought up in a animal enviroment from birth, and hadnt had respect for animals drilled into them by their parents.
By mari
Date 14.09.02 00:44 UTC
Hi Phillipa I know exactly what you mean and I agree .
I recall my Dad saying to us saucy dogs get torn jackets and that meant us as well lol:)
By Reefer
Date 14.09.02 07:52 UTC
Can I just defend 'non doggy' families a little:) We didn't have a dog as a family pet when I was growing up, but we were always taught respect of animals, and at a certain time in my life there were a fair few around:D
My kids have ALWAYS been taught respect of animals too, despite being classed I suppose as a non doggy family. DD came to us when my youngest was 15 months and it was the best thing I ever did:D OK he was an adult, but still please don't tar all us non doggy families with the same brush:) We all have to start somewhere you know;)
By philippa
Date 14.09.02 08:06 UTC
Oooooo Reefer, Im sorry, no offence was inteneded, and it was just a general comment. However, it still applies you see, because YOU were brought up to respect animals, and so have your children. Its more the " oh, lets get a dog shall we" kind of folk I was talking about. Sorry once again, didnt mean anything personal :(
By mari
Date 14.09.02 09:59 UTC
Morning Anita :) I did say some children were dog lovers from the cot not just mine .
I still say all children should never be allowed alone with a dog any dog .
it is way too dangerous for the child and the dog.
No offence intended to anyone who never had a dog, hand on heart :)
lol Mari
By Reefer
Date 14.09.02 12:45 UTC
Philippa:)
No I know you didn't Philippa, oh dear wish I hadn't said anything now, I didn't take it personally and mine too was a general comment:D And yes you are right about the 'oo lets get a dog' brigade. Far to few children are taught respect for anything these days.
Marie, I agree whole heartedly never ever leave the child alone with the dog. Accidents take a second to happen.
By philippa
Date 14.09.02 13:01 UTC
:D :D for Reefer

I used to take my dogs to pick up the kids from primary school. One family had a little girl that was frightened of dogs, much to her parents sadness as they wanted to have a dog. It seems that theri neighbours owned Two very hyper Border collies that jumped and barked at the fence. This frightened her.
After about a year with Dad coaxing an fussing the dogs she got up the courage to pet my Elkhounds.
A few months later I saw them at the scxhool with their new puppy a Whippet. they had gone for a gentle breed, feeling that she would cope far beter. This little bitch totally won me over as she was so playful and fun (I though all Whippets were aloof and dignified, lol). About 18 months later they got another one, and I sometimes met them in the park. The obvious raport of dogs and child was so evident. I think they were good for each other, as the dogs were far more outgoing than many Whippets owned by older people with no children, and the little Girls confidence had really grown.
I think the trick is to get to know th3e children in the family, and if you have any doubts whatever then do not sell to families with young children, or for that matter resentful teens!
Some children are just wonderful with dogs, having a natural affinity.
By jackyjat
Date 14.09.02 09:17 UTC
I totally agree with the earlier post by Mick. It is so important to emphasise the pecking order in the family home, my guess would be that Rhum was just trying to emphasise his place. My 9yr old son is confident with handling the dogs and really good with them but they don't see him as top dog as they do to me and my other 18yr old son who works them. Infact, even I come lower down in the pecking order than "the master" and their reaction time to me is definitely slower. Start the process of enforcing pecking order now.
By mr murphy
Date 14.09.02 09:32 UTC
Yes jacky the pecking order to a dog is important. A dog without a pecking order or a set of rules is not usually happy as they become confused. I think the dog may be a bit unsure of his position. I still feel a ten year old is too young to be feeding the dog or controling/reprimanding the dog unsupervised. I still think this child may get bitten
When I am at home the dogs (even my freinds dogs) see me as the leader and always look at me first before carrying out a command given by someone else. When I am not there my wife becomes the leader. If neither of us are there the dogs are locked up. Only my 19 year old daughter is allowed to take them out then. My son now 15 is never allowed to take them out.
I always get the impression that a lot of dog owners forget that a dog is not a little person despite all there cute human quirks. They are animals with a totaly different train of thought to humans. I beleive that this is the reason for most dog behavioural problems.
Id much rather be strict/safe than sorry.
Cheers Mick.
By issysmum
Date 14.09.02 13:13 UTC
I have 3 children (7 through to nearly 2) and Holly 9mth old Cocker. My oldest is very good with Holly and lets her out first thing in the morning as he's the first one to go downstairs. He comes into our room, stands on the bed to look out of the window to see if the gate is still locked then lets Holly out of her crate and into the garden.
Jonathon is really good with Holly and Holly is really good with him. He's not allowed to handle her food bowl, if she's got food in it and he doesn't do anything else with her until we come downstairs - unless it's raining then he gets her back inside and she goes straight into her crate.
Our youngest helps me feed Holly and sits on the floor next to Hollys crate and hand feeds her her dinner whilst I'm sitting with them and praising Holly for being a good dog.
Our middle child is awful, and isn't allowed anywhere near Holly if we're not in the room. I tell Holly to go in her pen if I have to leave the room as I can't trust my 4yr old not to start screaming that she's seen a spider or start jumping up and down because she's trying to dance to the music on the radio. All of this winds the puppy up and she just wants to play but Ellie is still a bit nervous of bouncy dogs and gets very upset.
We always control the situation when Holly and the children are together and we'd never let the oldest take Holly out for a walk, my 10yr old neice isn't allowed to either, but everyday over the school holidays we've had some neighbourhood children (6 and 5) ask if my eldest is coming out with Holly because they're taking their Springer pup for a walk. :( As my mum always says - if they're not old enough to babysit they're not old enough to be responsible for a dog.
The neighbours think I'm mean because I put Holly in her crate when we have strange children in the house, but I'm not prepared to take the chance of a problem between an excitable dog and non-dog sensible children.
Fiona
x x x
By mari
Date 14.09.02 18:10 UTC
Good for you Fiona. Mari:)
By Denise
Date 14.09.02 14:47 UTC
Shirley,
I think the last paragraph of your Post suggests where the problem lies - with yourself! - You say he can be 'protective' of his bones and space, and you feel this is probably normal behaviour for a dog, and therefore obviously accept it as such. (This is only 'normal' when a dog does not clearly understand his role in the Pack, and problems such as this then occur)! I know I will not be alone in saying that I cannot even begin to imagine any of my past or present dogs indicating any displeasure of my presence in their 'space' or feeding area, it simply is NEVER allowed to cross their minds!!
You also add that you feel you should respect his space and feeding area if that is what 'he' wants you to do!! - Your dog should not be demanding anything of you - YOU set the rules and code of behaviour, then YOU guide and train the dog to comply to those rules!
Unfortunately, (be it unwittingly) you are giving your dog areas of control that should not be allowed. This can lead to furthering his perspective of his powers of control over the 'pack' environment on a wider scale and in other ways too!
Dogs are dogs and people are people. Equality is not required by dogs, but they do have a compulsive need to know their place in the Pack. Trying to give a dog human emotions and responses is sadly not doing the dog justice.
You need to get back in the 'drivers seat', and make it clear to your dog that you are the Boss, and no allowances for any disagreeable attitude will be allowed or tolerated.
Regards,
Denise.
By mr murphy
Date 14.09.02 18:24 UTC
Well put Denise
Mick
By mari
Date 14.09.02 20:39 UTC
Absolutely Denise you have it in a nutshell
Mari
By Ingrid
Date 15.09.02 06:21 UTC
Sorry to disagree, but I feel that is is important for a dog to have it's own space, especially when there are kids in the house. As with Fiona and the crate, my dogs have always had there own corner where the kids where not allowed, if a dog retreated there it meant it wanted some time out and the kids knew to leave it alone. This doesn't mean it has to be protective, just know that it has a safe haven to get some peace and quiet. Ingrid
By Denise
Date 15.09.02 09:01 UTC
Hello Ingrid,
You may have mis-understood the essence of the dog's area of space/bed. A dog having a place to retreat and rest is good and fine, but a dog 'protecting' that area is NOT. (Shirley was indicating that her dog was 'protecting' his space)!
Parents have a responsibility to teach children to respect a dog who is resting, and not pull or poke or generally be a nuisance. I often hear people say "My dog is so good with the children, they can do anything with him". To which I always reply "I hope equally the children are good with the dog"!!
A dog should not CONTROL the area surrounding his/her place of rest. He should simply learn to recognise that he can rest without being 'teased'. A dog showing any form of 'control' over the human pack is indicating a lack of control and training by the Owner. This situation very rarely remains focussed on the one issue, the dog often progresses his control and the situation begins to escalate, (be it very subtly at first)!
To help understand how this can escalate, I have been called to people who have a problem where the dog is fed. They place the bowl down, and then retreat, leaving the dog to eat privately. However, before long, when someone happens to move too close to the feeding bowl the dog warns them off. Before long, no member of that family can even enter the room when the dog is feeding because he has now extended his control!
Both dogs and children need to be trained to learn a healthy respect for one another.
Regards,
Denise.
By Ingrid
Date 15.09.02 14:33 UTC
Denise, I am perhaps now beginning to understand why a behaviourist friend says I would be a nightmare to work with if I had problem dogs!!!
I probably break just about every rule in the book, feed the dogs and walk out of the room unless I am working there, let them have a their own small space, go out doors first (well who wants to walk out in front on a cold wet winter day), and luckily I haven't had problems where myself or members of the family have been challenged. I have my own trick for making them part with things, doesn't involve hitting, shouting or bribery, and always works first time, they rarely refuse a 2nd. Ingrid
Powered by mwForum 2.29.6 © 1999-2015 Markus Wichitill