
It's not a
sweeping statement - it's my view
on the quality of the contestants which made it through to the televised rounds which I watched - and as it happens I think they were woeful :) The UK is considerably smaller and voters a mere fraction of those for the US shows yet nobody IMO that made the final 10 was worthy of a job in a club or holiday camp. I don't doubt for a moment that the US show could be over loaded with fabulously talented singers - it's just that it wasn't :)
Re the geek / freak comment, again, it still applies because it's what
I think he looks like and I don't like his voice at all.