Sorry nothing was supposed to be a telling off just an explanation about the relationship or trials of the relationship between the dog artists and the art world in case people didn't understand what I am looking for and why.
I have spent hours and hours over the year wading through endless web site looking at dog artists and very few are all that good .. and very many are superb.. maybe at least a good 10% + of dog artists are what should fit the bill for recognition in art galleries if the trend were not dictated by the need of work to be off beat . It is these type of works which do include all the artists people have mentioned who are all top artists and I have thanked you all for these names and I have not said they are no good ) This is why it is really helpful to gain other insights into who dog lovers love too as artists. I wanted to explain in greater depth that I'm not just asking for names because I am being too lazy to look myself but that extra input is really helpful.. so I am not at all meaning to be telling anyone off. I really appreciate the help and any individual input people can give is valuable for my study.
Basically I doubt even the likes of Renoir would have their work accepted in galleries right now but that's not to say a Student wouldn't have a valid argument to base a study on to claim his work has a justifiably valid contribution to make to the art world.
I may be wrong but I dont personally think most of us really have quite the same passion or care about what is represented in our local gallery if we can find what we want easily in other places.ah we may not be drawn to galleries now because the work may well be of no interest to us but if the works of our favourate dog artists were exhibited in our city art galleries many of us would go to look.
So your comments on Debbie Gillingham are exactly what I am looking for. Perfect! If people can actually comment on the work like you have it is very useful to me because then I can add what is special the artists work. I decided as well as identifying one artist I will do a supplementary study where I can draw in several artists and their specialisms.
oooh boy is my art tutor is realy going to hate this! I get into enough trouble already for my dog related art work especially the ones that other people love. But it's what I love and is why I draw.
Mick Cawson is the artist who is best in my eyes because his work speaks to me, I love his vibrancy and the powerful use of light and colour... but that is my taste. And I am interested in what other people love and why if people have the time to think about it as you have done it would be great.

Okay and yes cos he paints border Collies too! ;)