
In breeds with a very wide gene pool and more than enough litters being bred I would discourage anyone from breeding that wasn't involved deeply with their bred in showing or working.
In my numerically small breed yes, as long as the bitch owner realises their responsibilities, adheres to the requirements of our breed clubs code of ethics, and has Hip scored and eye tested their bitch with good results, and the bitch is a good representative of the breed.
In such a case the breeder of the bitch will be fully involved with advising an appropriate sire, and helping the fledgling breeder, and in practice taking on most of the responsibilities re advice and support for the new puppy owners, as the breeders experience may be insufficient.
In fact one of my waiting list has just purchased a pup from such a breeder, and I as the breeder of the stud used, and also the the breeder of the bitch are available for support.
The bloodlines of the litter are excellent, and if the bitch had been shown she would not have disgraced herself. In fact some of the pups are going to Holland to enlarge their gene pool as the breeder has relatives involved in the breed there.
In practice this would not happen with a male as no-one would want to use it unless they had seen it in the ring, unless the breeder themselves wanted to use it on a bitch they or more likely a friend had.
In fact it is a shame that males in Pet homes who may be very good don't get used, but you can't use what you don't know is there, so unless the new dog owner comes to club events no-one will know a male that mght suit there bitch is around, and we continue to have to use the few available males. The situation isn't helped when Pet owners are encouraged to whip the balls of every pup by the time it is 6-9 months old in many cases.
Many in the breed have invested in importing dogs to enhance the gene pool, and this is truly an investment in the breeds future as after the costs involved with importation, and campaigning a dog, your are never going to get a return financially in stud fees, as males won't get enough stud use, and shouldn't as their genes will just saturate the gene pool if used more than a couple of times a year, over say a five year period.
I have considered sending my bitches abroad for mating, but the cost is prohibitive when any resulting pups are likely to be wasted (as far as the breed is concerned) in Pet homes.
Interestingly enough in Australia where there are very few of my breed bred and few breeders Pet dogs are used all the time. breeders are often restricted in the number of dogs theya re allowed to keep. the lady I exported to is only allowed to keep four adults, so people need to get very vreative to ahve a viable breeding program.
Owners of Pet males wity useful lines are encouraged to keep them entire, have them hip scored and eye tested. Some of the problems inherent in using Pet owned untried males is overcome by the use of fresh Artificial Insemination. Also removes soem of the reservations the males owners may have about having a stud dog.